Tuesday, November 29, 2011
Empowerment is the true embodiment of trust.
'Yes,' I reply, 'my father treated me to the most demanding discipline. He trusted me!'"
- Robert Galvin, former CEO Motorola
Galvin wasn't talking about trust as much as he was about empowerment. Empowerment is the true embodiment of trust. Without it, trust is just a word.
Sunday, November 20, 2011
Daniel Pink: Drive (me crazy).
In preparation for a presentation next week on motivation I picked up Daniel Pink’s book Drive. I’d picked it up once before and couldn’t remember why I didn’t finish reading it. Now I remember why. It is the fundamental premise of the book, summed up by Pink himself:
"Cocktail Party Summary: When it comes to motivation, there’s a gap between what science knows and what business does. Our current business operating system–which is built around external, carrot-and-stick motivators–doesn’t work and often does harm. We need an upgrade. And the science shows the way."
Really? Our current business operating system is built around external, carrot-and-stick motivators? That is like saying a deck of cards consists of red cards. Not entirely false, since red cards are in the deck, but not sufficiently true to hold up to a quick scrutiny. After all, half the cards are black. It is true that some managers use a carrot-and-stick motivational mode. But there have always been businesses that have been led by far more thoughtful and insightful leaders.
We don’t need science to show us the way, since the path has been well travelled by many business leaders long before the scientist studied the issue. Robert Galvin at Motorola stands tall in this crowd. He wrote:
“A wiser man put it thus: We measure the effectiveness of the true leader not in terms of the leadership he exercises but in terms of the leadership he evokes; not in terms of his power over others, but in terms of the power he releases in others; not in terms of the goals he sets and the directions he gives but in terms of the plans of action others work out for themselves with his help; not in terms of decisions made, events completed and the inevitable success and growth that follow from such released energy but in terms of growth in competence, sense of responsibility and in personal satisfaction among many participants.”
Thus, Pink answers a question that’s been answered many times before. A more interesting question might be, “Why is it that, when the evidence supporting the effectiveness of great leadership is so evident, do we still find managers using techniques that deliver mediocre results?" There must be something compelling in using coercion to control behavior in others. That would make for a more interesting psychological study.
Daniel Pink and other business writers are jumping to a solution. Showing that a particular behavior is a more successful behavior has always proven insufficient to cause adoption of that behavior. Just ask any parent. This reminds me of the metaphor of the elephant and the rider. The elephant is our emotional brain, our wants, needs, desires, and impulses. The rider is our rational, thinking, planning brain. Laying out what makes for a better management practice addresses the rider’s need. But clearly the elephant has a different behavior in mind. When the elephant wants to go one way and the rider another, guess which wins.
Lets redefine the problem: What is so compelling about management styles, broadly represented as carrot-and-stick methods, that causes managers to use them, when we know these methods are less effective in achieving stated company goals. How do we replace that behavior with a more effective one?
Monday, November 14, 2011
Foot Steps in the direction of the Holy Grail of Sales
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Fire the Hiring Manager
“Hiring managers hire the people they like the most.” Here, the research is definitive1. Hiring managers hire the people they like the most. Why? Primarily because hiring managers have no training and no expertise in the art of how to pick the best candidate. That forces hiring managers to use whatever tools they have at hand to come to a choice. People like other people who are most like themselves. FREE WHITE PAPER: http://blog.peakinterview.com/files/7/2/0/1/6/270087-261027/HiringWhitePaperr2.pdf
Monday, October 3, 2011
Part 1 of AIMS - "How to" Analyze messages to motivate others.
Saturday, August 27, 2011
Career Strategy: Be a Level 5 Leader to your staff, but show the boss you’re a bit of a jerk.
No doubt every manager is familiar with the plethora of research which shows that an engaged workforce is substantially more productive than an unengaged or disengaged workforce. Research also suggests that the key to having a highly engaged workforce is the behavior of the leader. Almost all business leaders are familiar with Jim Collins’ Level 5 Leader who is self-effacing, reserved, quiet and who listens well. The Level 5 leader is the most adept at engaging the workforce.
In the July 2011 Harvard Business Review article Why Fair Bosses Fall Behind authors Wiesenfeld, Rothman, Wheeler-Smith and Galinsky point out that, “the most effective leaders are generally those who give employees a voice, treat them with dignity and consistency, and base decisions on accurate and complete information.” These are Level 5 Leaders, bosses who treat people fairly.
But here is the rub. According to the authors, your ambition to get to the top of an organization may be undermined by this ‘good boss’ behavior. In the article they suggest that decisions about high-level promotions most often center on perceptions of power, not fairness, and apparently, it is hard to be both -- powerful and fair.
However, other psychological research may suggest that there is something more fundamental going on here. Interestingly, the likely reason this is true could be due to how the human brain functions and how it evaluates human interactions.
The author’s claim that we base high-level promotions on perceptions of power is probably a bit off target. (Power, after all, isn’t really a competency.) Experience suggests that when we look to hire someone into senior management roles we look for people who have superior intelligence; who are highly competent; and who have established themselves as experts. And i
t is in this evaluation that the brain screws us up.
Neuroscientist suggest that if you want to be perceived as having superior intellect, as highly competent, and as an expert, you’d better go to the dark side: you’d better go negative.
According to neuroscience, in our brains, positive emotions act as signals that the environment is basically benign, while negative emotions signal that some problem or threat is at hand. The theory argues that negative emotional experiences and words trigger a distinct, elaborate and detailed style of cognitive interpretation, whereas positive experiences and words trigger more general and script-based cognitive processing. In other words, our brains work much harder when we are processing the negative than when we process the positive.
It turns out that when the brain is working harder, it evaluates the interaction as more intelligent - it takes more brain-power to process, therefore it is more intellectually stimulating, therefore more intelligent.
The next time you’re in a meeting, and the boss starts a sentence with “I think...” pay attention to how people in the room agree with the boss. (Don’t worry about the people who disagree with the boss, if the boss says “I think” then these people are probably on their way out the door.) For the people who agree with the boss, you’ll see two kinds of responses.
The first will go something like this. Suppose the boss says something like “Well, I think our customers are perfectly content with our current three color options.” The response will be agreeable: “You are absolutely right boss, our customer are delighted with the current color schemes, we should just keep those in place for the foreseeable future.”
The second person will say something like this, “The people in this company

who keep pushing for more color options, well I just don’t understand them. If they’d put the slightest effort into really trying to understand what our customers value, and why they buy from us, they wouldn’t be wasting our precious time and resources on this nonsense. I am very happy, boss, that you see this so clearly. I couldn’t agree more, our current color offerings are spot-on and we should be focussing on more important issues.”
Of these two people, whom do you think is the climber? It’s the second one, of course. So, if there are any Machiavellian Princes out there, here is the cunning duplicity for you: Be a Level 5 Leader to the people who report to you and who you depend upon to be as engaged and productive as possible. To your boss and his or her peers, appear to be a bit of an jerk; not too much, but provide an ample enough negative positioning to appear to be more intelligent, more competent and more of an expert. Then, when they make you CEO, bury the jerk and be a great leader.
(Oh, and I should mention that there are two distinct ways to structure negatives. Psychology suggests that one way is far more effective than the other. Want to know more?...)


